• Blog
  • About
  • Reviews
  • Great Series Read Project
  • Archive

SciFi Mind

Visions of Future Worlds

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Goodreads
  • Mastodon
You are here: Home / Reviews / Ursula K. Le Guin’s Always Coming Home: Dialogue Between Present and Future

Ursula K. Le Guin’s Always Coming Home: Dialogue Between Present and Future

By John Folk-Williams

When Samuel R. Delany reviewed Ursula K. Le Guin’s Always Coming Home on its publication in 1985, he referred to science fiction as a dialogue between present and future. That happens to be a good way of thinking about this unique work. It is part imaginary ethnography and part literary anthology of a people, the Kesh, who “might be going to have lived a long, long time from now in Northern California.” The book is also part commentary on how the imagination combines fact and fiction. It portrays in rich detail a culture that might take the place of the one we know while using remnants of a lost society like our own.

Compendium of a Future Culture

Rather than explain this future world in a continuous narrative, Le Guin presents numerous examples of Kesh cultural and artistic practices. There are stories, poems, songs and one extended narrative. In a section called the Back of the Book, there are descriptions of Kesh language, kinship, religious practices, music, clothing, food, houses and much else that helps explain their complex culture. The original edition also included a recording of Kesh songs.

Though imbued with stories of Native American life by her anthropologist father, Alfred Kroeber (author of Handbook of the Indians of California) and her mother, Theodora Kroeber, who wrote ISHI In Two Worlds: A Biography of the last Wild Indian in North America, Le Guin rejected the idea of copying a Native American culture and pasting it into the future. There are echoes of native cultures (such as a Coyote figure) in Kesh stories and practices, but for the most part Le Guin created something new. She envisioned a culture blending respect for nature with the self-sustaining remnants of a technological society.

Pandora’s Commentary

Le Guin ties together the disparate elements of this compilation through the editorial efforts and commentary of Pandora, a cross-cultural interpreter who is very much the artist shaping our introduction to this future world.

Pandora is at once a contemporary of ours, interpreting the People’s culture like an anthropologist, but also an interviewer of the People of the Na Valley (based on the Napa Valley of California where Le Guin spent much of her childhood). She records their stories and songs and helps us reconstruct in our imaginations the villages and physical structures of their world, which does not yet exist in ours. So she is also a being out of time who reflects upon her role and worries about what she is doing.

She recoils from looking through the narrow end of the telescope, as she puts it, where everything looks ordered and doll-house like. She wants to run out to touch and hold things, to feel their weight, not to think of them intellectually but hold them in mind, not look for spiritual realities but to feel the heaviness of things.

Our language, she seems to say, and our minds want to grasp things abstractly, see them as wholes but have trouble looking into the thousands of tiny details of which the landscape is made. And so she has given us so many details to grasp but few of the generalizations that the mind wants to formulate. She asks the reader to live in the concrete details of this future world but also offers enough by way of explanation to pose tantalizing questions about our present.

The City of Mind

The Kesh people and their neighbors live amid the remnants of past civilizations. Although they live mostly in a farming and handcraft culture, there are trains that run on wooden rails, indoor plumbing and electricity and, most spectacularly, an extensive system of computers. These form a network that is fully automated and self-regulating, comprising “communities of cybernetic devices or beings”. There are access points to the network, called exchanges, all over the planet.

The Kesh use them to download information about any form of technology they wish to use, though they do this sparingly, and in return upload information about their lives and culture. The system contains comprehensive information about all human cultures, every branch of science and all forms of technology. The Kesh call this network, which is capable of conscious, self-directed evolution, the City of Mind in contrast to human civilization, the City of Man.

Stone Telling’s Life-Story

Le Guin invites the reader to get into the book in any way they choose. Each time I approach Always Coming Home, I start at a different point. Like most who look to fiction for a good story, I first began with the longer narrative about the life of Stone Telling. The length of a short novel, the story is broken into three parts and interspersed with numerous examples of Kesh poetry, songs, stories and descriptions of fundamental beliefs.

The narrator, whose name in old age is Stone Telling, presents the story of her learning how to be human, moving from her childhood to her rebellious teen years into her late twenties. She grows up in the household of her Kesh mother but is drawn to her father of the warrior Dayao people when he revisits his family after many years’ absence.

Feeling alienated from her mother, who is distant, she is drawn to him partly because he has come back after long absence to see her. She persuades him to take her with him to live in a city far north of the Na Valley. Even though she leaves her mother behind in anger, as she makes the long journey to the north (probably around Mt. Shasta), she feels the pull of the valley. It’s like leaving her body behind, reducing herself to a weightless entity.

Contrasting Cultures

She soon learns that the Dayao have no respect for women and keep them shut indoors, regarding them as having value only for the children they bear. Her father is a favorite general of the Condor, the absolute ruler of the Dayao people, and he travels frequently on military campaigns.

Their whole society starkly contrasts with the life she has known. The Kesh believe in a constant exchange with other living things, cultivation of the arts and writing and a rich ceremonial life shared by all. The Dayao women and children must stay indoors, away from nature. Neither they nor anyone else except for the Condor himself is allowed to read or write. That is because this society is guided by power, and the power of words is another dimension of the perfect being of the God they worship, known as the One.

They restrict access to all knowledge, limiting its sources to the household of the Condor. The people never discuss issues in public to reach agreement but rely wholly on their leader. Though the warriors, all men in this militarized society, travel constantly on their campaigns to subdue other lands, they never learn how other people live. They see other peoples as beneath them and good only to be turned into slaves. They think in binaries (either/or) and are not comfortable amid the diversity of living things.

Woman Coming Home

She has an arranged marriage and gives birth to a child, but has little feeling for the man she has married. She decides to leave that world and return to the Na Valley. Her slow journey reawakens her to the ways of being in the world that she has missed. The experience is so powerful that she renames herself Woman Coming Home.

This is not just a story of coming of age but of learning what it means to be a person. It is a great theme that recurs throughout the varied writings Le Guin has assembled, including the many shorter life stories and the fragment of a Kesh novel, called “Dangerous People.” I have never encountered so rich a dramatization of what it means to realize the self within the context of a particular place and a finely imagined culture.

Merging Reality and Imagination

The new Library of America edition of Always Coming Home includes a further section of essays and stories selected by Le Guin that offers insight into the way she approached this book. She added one story that she says showed her the way to write about this world, even though ultimately she found no place for it in the finished product.

“May’s Lion” is an excellent place to find a way in for the reader, just as it was for Le Guin. In a prefatory note, she rejected the usual “trickster’s” way of moving from the reality of the Napa Valley she knew to the imagined Na Valley of the future by “concealing the connection,” between the factual and the imaginary. Instead, she decided to leave that connection out in plain sight.

She tells the story of May, an elder neighbor, finding a mountain lion under the fig tree near her house. May figured it was ill and was looking for a place to die. It stayed there all day and kept her in the house, unable to get to the nearby pasture to milk her cow. Finally, at a loss for what to do, she called the sheriff, who arrived with deputies and guns. They were at a loss too but wound up doing the only thing they knew how to do. They shot and killed the lion. May didn’t want that, but she just didn’t know what else to do.

Stepping Outside History

Le Guin then retells the story by taking May and the lion outside of history, as she says, and putting them into the Na Valley, where May’s name means Rains End in the Kesh language and she has been a healer for many years. She waits patiently to observe the lion under her fig tree and decides that he has probably come there to die. She doesn’t know the songs of mountain lions, but she sings for him the songs that humans use when they are dying. Rains End falls asleep sitting on the porch of her house, and in the morning sees that the lion ‘had finished his dying” and so she sings the last song over him. Later she gets help from friends to carry the lion out “where the buzzards and coyotes could clean it.”

It’s a beautiful story that connects with the reader without a lot of background explanation, in much the way that the poems, songs and stories of Always Coming Home do. This is a book that demands to be reread and that only grows in richness through the encounter with more details and stories of Kesh culture.

Related Posts

  • What is Science Fiction Ursula K. Le Guin
    Ursula K. Le Guin on What Is Science Fiction?

    When I started this blog, I considered having a page offering various answers to the…

  • 10 Great SFF Books Coming This Fall

    Here I am only half way through my short summer TBR list, and already I…

  • The Lathe of Heaven by Ursula KM. Le Guin
    The Lathe of Heaven by Ursula K. Le Guin - Vintage Science Fiction Month

    I'm starting off my Vintage Science Fiction Month with Ursula K. Le Guin’s The Lathe…

Filed Under: Reviews Tagged With: Always Coming Home, ceremonial life, culture, nature, power, story-telling, technology, Ursula K. Le Guin

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe to SciFi Mind Posts



About SciFi Mind

nebula SciFiMind

Something is struggling to be born in this damaged and inspiring world, and I believe science fiction and its speculative cousins are helping us figure out what it is. It’s pushing the imaginations of fiction writers to bend and twist familiar forms to try to capture the forces that are hurling us into a barely conceivable future. This blog is my small way of exploring the half-perceived … Read More about About

Search SciFi Mind

Recent Posts

  • Furious Heaven by Kate ElliottFurious Heaven by Kate Elliott – Book 2 of The Sun Chronicles
  • The Mimicking of Known SuccessesThe Mimicking of Known Successes by Malka Older
  • The Crane Husband by Kelly BarnhillThe Crane Husband by Kelly Barnhill
  • Untethered Sky by Fonda LeeUntethered Sky by Fonda Lee

Categories

Twitter

John Folk-Williams Follow

SFMind

JL Thank you for following me!!

Reply on Twitter 1638350925340327941 Retweet on Twitter 1638350925340327941 Like on Twitter 1638350925340327941 Twitter 1638350925340327941

The Fiction Addiction 📚 Thank you for following me!!

Reply on Twitter 1638199805301121024 Retweet on Twitter 1638199805301121024 Like on Twitter 1638199805301121024 Twitter 1638199805301121024

A fine review - this book is next on my list: nerds of a feather, flock together: Review: Some Desperate Glory by Emily Tesh http://www.nerds-feather.com/2023/03/review-some-desperate-glory-by-emily.html?spref=tw

Reply on Twitter 1637788987266940932 Retweet on Twitter 1637788987266940932 Like on Twitter 1637788987266940932 1 Twitter 1637788987266940932

Thanks for introducing me to another fine author: INFINITY GATE by M.R. Carey - Review https://booksbonesbuffy.com/2023/03/20/infinity-gate-by-m-r-carey-review/ via @tammy_sparks

Reply on Twitter 1637788691161546752 Retweet on Twitter 1637788691161546752 Like on Twitter 1637788691161546752 4 Twitter 1637788691161546752

Sounds like an incredible book: Why You Need to Read: "Assassin of Reality" https://mistyaquavenatus.com/2023/03/18/why-you-need-to-read-assassin-of-reality/ via @AquaVenatus #scifi #sff

Reply on Twitter 1637432091053813760 Retweet on Twitter 1637432091053813760 Like on Twitter 1637432091053813760 4 Twitter 1637432091053813760
Load More...

About the Author

A late-comer to the worlds of science fiction, John Folk-Williams circled around it, first by blogging (primarily through Storied Mind) about inner struggles and the mind’s way of distorting reality. Then he turned directly to SFF as an amazing medium for re-envisioning the mind and the worlds it creates. He started this blog as a way to experiment with writing science fiction and to learn from its many masterful practitioners.

Follow

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Goodreads
  • Mastodon

Privacy Policy

Privacy Policy

Cookie Policy

Cookie Policy

© 2023 Copyright by John Folk-Williams · Dynamik-Gen On Genesis Framework